A Philatelic Introduction to B.A.E. II: Cancellation Types

by

Paul Skowron, ASPP

 

FIRST CANCELLATION VARIETIES

ALL TYPES USED BY LEROY CLARK IN 1934

 

MACHINE CANCELLATIONS

TYPE I

7 KILLERS

JAN. 30, 1934

CLARK TYPE

TYPE II

7 KILLERS

JAN. 30, 1934

CLARK TYPE

TYPE III

7 KILLERS

JAN. 31, 1934

CLARK TYPE

 

 

HAND CANCELLATIONS

NOTE: NOT EXACT SIZE AS ORIGINAL; SOME DETAILS OMITTED FROM DIAL

TYPE I

  • SHORT KILLERS WRAP AROUND DIAL
  • JAN. 30 1934 DATE
  • "GAP" BETWEEN '30' AND '1934'
  • NO 'TIME' IN DIAL

TYPE II

  • SHORT KILLERS WRAP AROUND DIAL
  • JAN. 30 1934 DATE
  • NO "GAP" BETWEEN '30' AND '1934'
  • NO "TIME" IN DIAL
  • DIAL DISTORTION AT 5 O'CLOCK POSITION

TYPE III

  • SHORT KILLERS WRAP AROUND DIAL
  • JAN. 30 1934 DATE
  • "GAP" BETWEEN '30' AND '1934'
  • NO "TIME" IN DIAL
  • PERIOD AFTER 'LITTLE AMERICA' & 'ANTARCTICA'

 

 

FIRST & SECOND CANCELLATION VARIETIES

1934 POSTMARKS USED IN 1935

( BY CHARLES F. ANDERSON )

 

MACHINE CANCELLATIONS

NOTE: NOT EXACT SIZE AS ORIGINAL; SOME DETAILS OMITTED FROM DIAL

TYPE IV

6 KILLERS / JAN 31, 1934 DATE / ANDERSON TYPE

These types were used by Anderson to finish remaining mail "uncancelled" by Clark, or to redo improperly done covers. Hand cancel usage is normally found on covers with multiple franking (e.g. blocks), or where the postmark of a machine cancel is unreadable. In most cases the cancel has been turned or the killers masked out to avoid covering cachets or an address. All were marked with a San Francisco receiving cancel on the back of the cover.

 

HAND CANCELLATIONS

TYPE IV

  • LONG KILLERS WITH STRAIGHT SIDES
  • JAN. 31 1934 DATE
  • 8:30 PM TIME IN DIAL
  • DIAL DISTORTION ( 2 & 5 O'CLOCK)
  • BOTTOM BAR OFFSET 1/32"

TYPE V

  • LONG KILLERS WITH STRAIGHT SIDES
  • JAN. 31 1934 DATE
  • 8:30 PM TIME IN DIAL

TYPE VI

  • MEDIUM LENGTH KILLERS WITH STRAIGHT SIDES
  • JAN. 31 1934 DATE
  • 8:30 PM TIME IN DIAL

 

 

SECOND CANCELLATION VARIETIES

TYPES USED BY CHARLES F. ANDERSON IN 1935

 

MACHINE CANCELLATIONS

NOTE: NOT EXACT SIZE AS ORIGINAL; SOME DETAILS OMITTED FROM DIAL

 

TYPE V


11 MM SPACING

  • 6 KILLERS
  • JAN. 30 1935 DATE
  • TIME 12-M
  • NO PERIODS USED

TYPE VI      SPACING VARIETY


11+ MM SPACING

  • 6 KILLERS
  • JAN. 30 1935 DATE
  • TIME 12-M
  • NO PERIODS USED

 



HAND CANCELLATIONS

 

SHORT KILLERS
MEDIUM KILLERS
  • JAN. 30 1935 DATE
  • 2 PERIODS - AMERICA. & JAN.
  • TYPE SIZE NORMAL HEIGHT
  • SMALL GAP AT 3 & 9 O'CLOCK
  • JAN 30. 1935 DATE   TIME: 12-M
  • 2 PERIODS - AMERICA. & JAN.
  • TYPE SIZE NORMAL
  • SMALL GAP AT 3 & 9 O'CLOCK
  • "HEINMULLER" TYPE
  • JAN. 30 1935 DATE    TIME: 12-M
  • 2 PERIODS - AMERICA. & ANTARCTICA.
  • TYPE SIZE SMALL
  • LARGE GAP AT 3 & 9 O'CLOCK  
  • KILLERS WRAP AROUND DIAL
 
LONG KILLERS
  • JAN. 30 1935 DATE
  • TOPE KILLER TO RIGHT
  • DIAL DISTORTED AT 5 O'CLOCK
  • JAN. 30 DATE
  • "DROOPY" KILLER BARS
  • JAN. 30 1935 DATE
  • BOTTOM KILLER TO LEFT
   





NOTES ON ODD VARIETIES AS OF JANUARY 1992:

  • 5/8" Killers / Hal Vogel reports 1 H.C. / No Back-Up
  • 1 15/16" Killers / Hal Vogel reports 1 H.C. / No Back-Up
  • 2 1/4" Killers / Paul Skowron Reports 1 H.C. / No Back-Up

 

 

NATIONAL STAMP EXHIBITION OF 1934

HAND CANCEL TYPES

 

Three handcancelers were in use at the Exhibition Post Office . . . two with short killers and one with long killers. The short types ( I & II ), are very similar except that the "DATE" and "TIME" slugs in the postmarks are switched. As for the long killers, ( other than the normally centered "FEB", Type III ), it is known that a second long killer variety exists with the word "FEB" shifted left or right of center. This new variety ( Type IV ), is probably the result of a poorly functioning or "broken" Type III canceler, not a fourth cancelling device. This Type IV cancel moves out of alignment, in increments, both far right and left of center.

Reproductions of the four types are shown below:

 

TYPES I, II

 

  • SHORT KILLERS WRAP AROUND CIRCLE
  • TYPE I IS SHOWN AT LEFT
  • TYPE II IS NOT SHOWN - "DATE & TIME" ARE SWITCHED
  • BLACK & RED INKS USED (REGISTERED USE)

TYPE III

 

  • LONG KILLERS, ENDS VERTICAL
  • "DATE" & "TIME", TYPE I SEQUENCE
  • "FEB" SHIFTED TO THE RIGHT OR LEFT
  • BLACK INK IS USED
TYPE IV

 

  • LONG KILLERS AS TYPE III
  • "DATE" & "TIME", TYPE I SEQUENCE
  • "FEB" SHIFTED TO THE RIGHT OR LEFT
  • BLACK INK USED

 

B.A.E. II RECEIVING POSTMARK

SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA

 

NORMAL SIZE - 34mm

SMALLER SIZE - 33mm

The smaller size is shown above and may be used as an "overlay".

This new type was noted by Gunnar Carlson on a cover purchased in a 1996 Polar Bear Philatelics Auction

 

The vast majority of "Second Cancelation" and " . . . delayed . . . " mail serviced by Anderson in 1935 is marked on the back with a "San Francisco" receiving mark. However, some slipped through and are not backstamped.

Two basic types exist, the common machine types shown below . . .

 





For unknown reasons, there exist today 7 varieties of machine cancels. All appear, at quick glance, to be the same . . . but they are not. The example above shows dimensions of various elements of the cancel. Notice the length of killer does vary!

 

. . . and the uncommon hand type shown below:

 

 

Hand marks were used as favors, or on some crew mail. However, they were most often used when a cover slipped through without a machine marking. Hand type covers are uncommon, ones with both as shown above are even more uncommon.

 





As the above cover illustrates, it was after expedition and postal officials inspected the Little America covers and sent them on for delivery that any "receiving" marks were applied (dated June 8, 1934 on this example). These marks were applied, usually on the back, at the post office of the addressee. "Receiving" type covers from the First Cancellation (undelayed) are uncommon because postal rules were strict in this regard of backstamping ordinary mail (non-registered, special delivery, etc.).

Some First Cancelation mail is incorrectly backstamped as a result of collectors prevailing upon a willing postal clerk to bend the rules. The cover above illustrates a legitimate backstamping as an extra stamp was affixed to the rear of the cover for canceling.

Most, if not all covers, are backdated sometime in late May or early June of 1934.



CONTINUED ON THE NEXT PAGE